The church of sleep deprivation: How Scientology keeps its workers compliant and childless
Tony Ortega, Van Winkle’s
L. Ron Hubbards immensely powerful, immensely secretive religion is powered by a workforce of sleep-deprived ministers. And thats not the worst of it.
n December 7, a trial is scheduled to begin in Los Angeles that has been wending its way to a jury for more than six years. The plaintiff, a New Mexico woman named Laura DeCrescenzo, is suing the Church of Scientology for the abuse she allegedly suffered as a member of Scientologys hard-core inner elite, known as the Sea Organization.
Scientology fought all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court to try unsuccessfully to keep DeCrescenzos records as an employee and parishioner under wraps. These records tell a story that can seem unreal to someone not familiar with the Sea Org and its quasi-naval ranks and uniforms.
Its not just DeCrescenzo. Other former Sea Org workers talk of difficult, arguably abusive working conditions, from swabbing the decks of ocean-going vessels to cleaning toilets with toothbrushes to doing construction without any safety equipment.
What those stories all have in common is lack of sleep. As Van Winkles reports, there may be no more sleep-deprived workforce in the country than Scientologys Sea Organization.
Laura DeCrescenzo signed Sea Orgs infamous billion-year contract when she was 12-years-old. Right away, she was put on a schedule that beggars belief 14-hour days, seven days a week. Thats 98 hours in a week, for which she was paid $50 dollars, if she was lucky. As an organization with a religious purpose, Scientology uses the tax code to its advantage and plays loose with child labor laws, claiming that DeCrescenzo and other kids are ministers.
When she was 13, according to court filings, DeCrescenzo was moved to the adult schedule, and found herself working 16 hours a day without a day off. Thats 112 hours a week, or nearly triple the normal work schedule in this country. A photograph of DeCrescenzo in her teens shows her head slumped over as she sits at her desk, asleep on the job. The image captures an essential component of what its like to work for Scientology.
Now in its 62nd year, the Church of Scientology claims among its ranks many second- and third-generation members. Many brought into the church dont know any better. And, unless they manage to break free, they may never learn any other lifestyle.
But even for those who are blown or, in Scientology lingo, have escaped and disavowed the Church theres the issue of recollection.
The problem with trying to remember the effects of sleep deprivation is that you cant remember, said former Scientology spokesman Mike Rinder, who worked in the Sea Org for decades. It makes you stupid. Stupid and controllable.
Like DeCrescenzo, Rinder was brought into Scientology as a child and knew nothing else. He finally left the organization in 2007, and he is one of the former members featured in Alex Gibneys HBO documentary, Going Clear, which won three Emmys for exposing many of the hardships of the Sea Org.
(Disclosure: I also appeared in that documentary, owing to my own investigations and research into Scientologys practices, as chronicled in my journalism, on my website and in my book, The Unbreakable Miss Lovely.)
You lose your willingness to fight back or challenge or try to think about whats happening to you, and why, or what it means, Rinder said in an interview from his home this month. You just kind of go along. And I think thats the best description of the end result of sleep deprivation.
Rinder and other former Sea Org members point to sleep deprivation as one of the Churchs most effective methods of control. Its not hard to understand why its effective. A report by the U.S. Senate Select Committee on Intelligence revealed that, following the 9/11 attack, the CIA employed sleep deprivation as one of its enhanced techniques that critics have since characterized as torture.
We were on short sleep endlessly, said Rinder. It was not unusual for me, especially before the big events, to sleep two hours a night on average for two weeks. Some might be six hours, others were nothing. Maybe a nap. But it would go sometimes for weeks of ridiculous sleep deprivation.
Rinders roots in Scientology reach back nearly as long as the Church itself. His family joined Scientology after its founder, L. Ron Hubbard, made a visit to Australia in the 1950s. (Hubbard founded Scientology in 1952 and created his first Church of Scientology corporation in December 1953 in Camden, NJ.) Hubbard later ended up in England after authorities in the United States had launched various investigations about his movement.
In 1967, Hubbard left England and took Scientology to sea. He was joined by a few hundred young and dedicated followers on three ships that came to be known as the Apollo, the Athena and the Diana. For the next eight years, Hubbard ran Scientology from various ports in the Mediterranean and the Atlantic. He dubbed this crew the Sea Organization, and members were given naval ranks, with Hubbard himself Commodore. He put them through extreme rituals of discipline, even tossing some wayward crew members overboard.
Going to Clearwater
In 1975, Hubbard finally ended his ocean adventure and led a stealthy invasion of the Florida gulf coast town of Clearwater. To this day, Scientologys Clearwater complex is known as Flag after the Flagship command ship, the Apollo, which Hubbard called home. Those who run it and other Scientology locations are still known as the Sea Org.
Outside of Clearwater, one of Scientologys most important locations is the International Base, also known as simply Int or Gold, for the Golden Era Productions studios housed there. This 500-acre compound sits in the California desert near Hemet, about 90 miles east of Los Angeles. Only the most dedicated Sea Org members are allowed to work here, and most consider it a badge of honor.
This is also where Scientology leader David Miscavige spent most of his time. Miscavige is the most important living figure in Scientology, himself having joined as a teenager and eventually climbing the ladder to work as L. Ron Hubbards deputy; he took control of the organization after Hubbards death in 1986. It is Miscavige who succeeded in getting Scientology tax-exempt status in 1993.
Miscavige also had a habit of disregarding Sea Org members need for rest. It was common for Miscavige to come into our office and have a conversation with him while someone was sleeping in a fetal position on the floor with their coat rolled up under their head, said Marc Headley, who also grew up in Scientology. Headley worked at the Int Base for 15 years before making a mad dash for freedom, which he described in his 2009 book, Blown for Good.
One time, I had a conversation with Miscavige, and the brand name of the tape machine Id been using was imprinted on my face because Id fallen asleep on it, he said. Miscavige himself, Headley pointed out, would work until three or four in the morning but he slept in until about noon.
Sea Org workers like Headley didnt give any thought to that discrepancy. He had a job to do, no matter the unrealistic demands put upon his schedule. The secret to sleep deprivation is cat naps, he said, laughing.
One incident wasnt so funny. Headley and other workers were assigned to work with recording machines that manufactured audiotapes of Hubbard lectures. When a master tape was ready, they made duplicates on various machines. If a new master wasnt ready, they had a chance to take a short break and maybe a quick nap.
The guy who handled the master tapes wasnt so lucky. He simply never took a break, even for a short while, as the others waited for him to make their duplicates.
The guys record for staying up was seven days straight, Headley said. And then one day, he disappeared.
The first day, we assumed hed blown, Headley said, using the term for escaped.
But then, on the second day, we found him. The guy had walked into a room we werent using and just laid down on the floor and went into a deep sleep. But the floor was concrete which was very dangerous. A concrete floor sucks the body heat right out of a person. Hed slept on that floor for two days straight. Once they found him, he had to be rushed to a hospital. He nearly died of hypothermia.
Once they found him, he had to be rushed to a hospital. He nearly died of hypothermia.
Against the Church
As with other organizations that inspire blind, exhausting devotion among its members, Scientology employs another tactic to keep its Sea Org members motivated: fear.
As former Scientology spokesman Mike Rinder explained, You dont have the mental strength to fight about it. You would be under such a threat over the consequences of not being on your post that it became like, which is more painful not sleeping, or suffering the consequences of getting some sleep? You became your own alarm clock out of fear.
It wasnt just on-site duties that ate away at the members sleep schedules.
I used to drive back and forth between L.A. and the Int Base, Rinder said. I would have to drive the entire way with my head out the window, even in the winter time, to try and keep myself awake. I got pulled over a couple of times for swaying over the lanes, and they thought I was drunk.
These incidents, as Rinder described them, were insanely stupid and dangerous Those are circumstances where I would work for days and days with no sleep, and then literally pass out.
Perversely, the Church used photos of Rinder sleeping at his desk due to exhaustion in an attempt to discredit him and the Alex Gibney documentary, Going Clear. On the website for its official magazine, Freedom, the Church posted videos and photos, describing Rinder as The Sloth and Rip Van Rinder. The description of the video reads:
Alex Gibney and HBO anointed as the poster boy for their new film an admitted liar who was expelled from the Church, Mike Rinder. Its accurate to say he dreams up new myths and lies given hes usually asleep. Rip Van Rinder has perfected the art of nodding off and laziness. His former colleagues tell stories of his Rinder falling asleep anytime, anywhere. And no, its not because of any medical condition. He readily admits he doesnt like to work. So when it comes to Mike Rinder and his lies, one must always go in with eyes wide open. Even if Mike Rinder cant.
Portraying former Scientologists as incompetent is one of the Churchs common tactics. What makes the Rinder case so unusual, and compelling, is that he was Scientologys top spokesman for about 18 years. He knows how the organization works.
The control mechanism in the Sea Org is urgency. And its a phony urgency that somehow what we get done will have some impact on the world, he said.
The sleep deprivation ultimately results in a Catch-22. Youve become so much less efficient from lack of sleep that you cant do anything properly. And since you cant do anything properly, you have to stay up and redo it. Thats the hamster wheel of insanity that goes on in the Sea Org.
Marc Headley decided to flee Int Base on January 5, 2005. He had to keep his plans a secret, even from his wife, Claire.
He radioed me with his Nextel phone and asked if I was coming home, Claire recalled. The couple lived in an apartment on the base, which they got to use very little. She told Marc that she was going to try to get home, but she was still working.
I never made it home to shower, she said. I had been dozing at my desk for about an hour, and a person came in and said, Marcs driving down Highway 79 right now on his motorcycle. In other words, they knew he was escaping. Claire offered to go after her husband, to try to recover him to the base. But, from leaderships perspective, it was too late. She was told, Hes an enemy now.
I knew the drill, Claire said. She had to make the other workers believe that shed had nothing to do with Marcs escape, and that she was now turning her back on her husband. She also went into extreme sleep deprivation. I knew that sleeping an hour or so a night reduced my chances of being sec checked, she said, referring to the brutal security interrogations of those suspected of working against the Church.
Before long, Claire made her own escape and was reunited with Marc, and they then set about doing what they werent allowed to do in the Sea Org: have a family. They now live in Colorado with their three young boys.
And thats where the most insidious of Scientology policies enters the picture: From the early 1980s or mid-1990s, depending on which source you consult, it was against policy for Sea Org workers to have children. This held true until about 2010, when the Tampa Bay Times first exposed the practice of church officials pressuring pregnant Sea Org women to get abortions.
Sleep deprivation, say former members Gary Morehead and Gary Weber, was central to enforcing this policy.
For the record, Scientology has denied coercing abortion among its members. But in 2010, a spokesman, Tommy Davis, did admit to the Tampa Bay Times that there had been a longtime policy against having children in the Sea Org.
Twice, Claire Headley says, she was forced to have abortions in the Sea Org. I didnt have a choice, she told the Tampa Bay Times for their video series, No Kids Allowed, produced in 2010. If I had said, Im not going to do this, I wouldve been separated from my husband. The possibilities were endless. I knew I wouldve had serious punishments levied. I wouldve been on manual labor. I was concerned for what would happen to my child. So, I did not have a choice.
Another former member who makes this claim is Laura DeCrescenzo, the New Mexico woman whose abuse trial is scheduled for December 7. When Laura was 16, she married another Sea Org worker. At 17, Laura got pregnant. In her court depositions, she testified that was told an abortion would be the greatest good for the greatest number of dynamics, a Scientology slogan used to assure loyalty to the group.
DeCrescenzos accusation that she was given no choice but to terminate her pregnancy which she later regretted is central to her lawsuit. (In its court briefs, Scientology has denied that DeCrescenzo was coerced, and says that her decision was her own.)
Two men have also come forward with similar stories, saying they not only witnessed the incidents but abetted them. One, Gary Morehead, was the chief of security at Int Base. A few years ago, he sat down with filmmaker Mark Bunker and talked about the subtle task of making sure pregnant Sea Org workers went along with the program. In a clip Bunker posted to YouTube, Morehead explained his process:
We would address the sensitivity of it, but it would be to the benefit of the group. It wasnt like, Listen, bitch, you need to get an abortion. It was like, Hey, listen, you know, how you doing? And who was the best person to have that conversation with them? If their father or their mother was on staff, youd go that route. And the girl would be convinced to have an abortion. Or she would come out and say, so fearful, that she would herself self-elect, say, I need to get an abortion.
Morehead and another former Sea Org employee, Gary Weber, make it clear that extreme sleep deprivation contributed to their subjects malleability.
Sleep deprivation was an ingredient of the Kool-Aid mix that kept us all there, Morehead said, adding that the lack of sleep was a significant factor in his ability to talk women into going for abortions. There was also an unflagging belief that having children detracted from Scientologys goal of clearing the planet.
Claire Headley corroborates this. Sleep deprivation was a big reason why I stayed there as long as I did, she said. My powers of reasoning were worn down by the extreme lack of sleep. Quite literally I could not think straight or see myself out of the nightmare I was stuck in. The last year it would be safe to say that I could count the number of nights I slept a full night on two hands. And the number of nights I slept not a wink were too numerous to count.
Laura DeCrescenzos lawsuit has traveled a very complex road to trial, and its not there yet. A new hurdle was recently thrown in its path. Last month, Church of Scientology lawyers filed another motion for summary judgment; a previous motion was dismissed in 2013.
This time, the Church has asked the court to dismiss DeCrescenzos lawsuit because it is a church and its treatment of Sea Org workers however perceived by the outside world is protected under the religious freedom guaranteed in the First Amendment.
This strategy has worked for Scientology in the past. Its entirely possible that DeCrescenzos case may never see a courtroom.
A request for comment about the Sea Orgs extreme work hours and the claims of coerced abortion was sent to the church. No reply was received by press time. We will update this article if we receive any comment from the Church of Scientology.